Home / Types of Editing
Three tiers of document editing showing substantive, copy, and proofreading levels

Types of Editing: Which Does Your Manuscript Need?

One of the most common points of confusion for researchers preparing a manuscript is understanding exactly what kind of editorial intervention they need. The terms "editing" and "proofreading" are often used interchangeably in everyday conversation, but in academic publishing they refer to quite different levels of intervention — and choosing the wrong type can waste time and money while still leaving your manuscript unpublishable.

There are three distinct tiers of academic editing, and understanding the difference is essential before you engage any editorial service or begin a self-editing pass.

Substantive Editing (Also Called Developmental or Content Editing)

Substantive editing is the most intensive form of editorial work. A substantive editor engages with the argument, structure, and logic of your manuscript — not just the language. This type of editing is appropriate when:

  • Your manuscript has structural problems (the argument does not flow logically from introduction to conclusion)
  • Key sections are underdeveloped (the discussion does not sufficiently interpret the results)
  • The scope is unclear (the paper tries to do too much or the research question is poorly defined)
  • Reviewers have returned the paper with substantive critiques about argument or methodology

Substantive editing is the most time-intensive and expensive form of editing because it requires the editor to have expertise in your subject area. An editor working on a biochemistry manuscript must understand the field well enough to evaluate whether the interpretation of results is defensible.

According to the Council of Science Editors, substantive editing should occur before copyediting — it makes no sense to polish prose that may later need to be restructured or deleted.

Key Principle If you read your manuscript out loud and find yourself struggling to explain what a paragraph is arguing, you need substantive editing — not proofreading.

Copyediting

Copyediting operates at the sentence and paragraph level. A copyeditor does not restructure your argument, but they do:

  • Correct grammatical errors, including agreement, punctuation, and usage
  • Improve sentence clarity — replacing vague or awkward constructions with precise ones
  • Ensure consistency: consistent spelling of technical terms, consistent use of abbreviations, consistent number formatting
  • Apply the style guide requirements of your target journal (APA, AMA, Chicago, Vancouver, etc.)
  • Check that figures and tables are correctly referenced in the text
  • Verify that the reference list format matches the journal requirements

Copyediting comes after substantive editing and before proofreading. It is the appropriate intervention for manuscripts that are structurally sound but need language polish — which describes the situation of most researchers who are writing in their second language.

There are two levels of copyediting: single-check (one editor reviews the manuscript) and double-check (a second editor verifies the changes made by the first). For manuscripts going to high-impact journals, double-check copyediting significantly reduces the risk of error reaching reviewers.

Proofreading

Proofreading is the final quality check before submission. It assumes that all substantive and language issues have been resolved and focuses exclusively on surface errors that survived earlier editing:

  • Typographical errors (typos)
  • Spacing inconsistencies
  • Formatting errors (incorrect heading levels, misaligned tables)
  • Final reference list verification
  • Page number and header accuracy

Proofreading is appropriate only for manuscripts that have already been through at least one round of careful copyediting. Sending a manuscript that still contains substantive or language errors for proofreading only will not produce a submission-ready document — the proofreader's scope does not extend to fixing those problems.

Which Type Do You Need?

The honest answer is that most manuscripts submitted for the first time need at least copyediting, and many need substantive editing as well. A useful self-diagnostic:

  • If the argument is unclear → substantive editing
  • If the argument is clear but the language is rough → copyediting
  • If only typos and formatting remain → proofreading

Understanding these distinctions allows you to seek precisely the right level of support and to get your manuscript submission-ready as efficiently as possible.